Hello dear
Welcome To Seminole Tap
Welcome to Seminole Tap, a vibrant bar situated at 5956 Executive Dr, Fitchburg, WI. Known for its diverse menu, Seminole Tap strives to offer an enjoyable dining experience, highlighted by fan-favorite dishes like their delicious wings and flavorful burgers. Customers rave about the friendly service and the laid-back atmosphere, making it a go-to spot for casual gatherings. The margaritas have emerged as local favorites, capturing the essence of Wisconsin bar culture. Though some reviews note room for improvement in acoustics and side dishes, the overall sentiment reflects a commitment to quality and a welcoming vibe. Your next culinary adventure awaits here!
Taste the best
Discover Our Menu
Traditional Wings
US$12.00Chicken Wrap
US$14.00Fried or Baked Walleye
US$23.00
Fried or Baked Cod
US$17.00Soup of the Day
US$7.00Chili
US$7.00
Ceaser Salad
US$9.00Ginger Sesame
US$13.00Mixed Greens
US$9.00 About
Seminole Tap
Welcome to Seminole Tap, a vibrant dining destination nestled at 5956 Executive Dr, Fitchburg, WI. This inviting establishment has quickly made a name for itself in the local food scene, drawing patrons in with its eclectic menu and friendly service. Whether you're craving classic barfare or a refreshing cocktail, Seminole Tap caters to a variety of tastes and preferences.
Our recent reviews offer a glimpse into the dining experience at Seminole Tap. Here, you'll find an atmosphere that buzzes with energy. While some guests have noted that the sound levels can sometimes be a challenge, especially in the larger section of the restaurant, the overall conviviality amplifies the experience. A special shout-out goes to the helpful staff who manage to maintain a good level of attentiveness, even during the busy dinner rush.
For those with a penchant for wings, this spot does not disappoint. Diners rave about the flavor-packed wings complemented by homemade hot sauce. You might also want to indulge in their cheese curds, a local favorite that pairs perfectly with a beverage from their bar—a place where deals like $3 PBR cans and robust bacon smash burgers further entrench it as a go-to spot in the area.
The culinary offerings extend beyond wings and cheese curds. Many visitors have enjoyed the Rueben sandwich, which though could use a bit more crispiness, is packed with flavor. The fries, made in beef tallow, have garnered a lot of attention, with guests expressing hopes for consistent preparation throughout. It’s these little details, like the cleanliness of the facilities and the friendliness of the waitstaff, that elevate Seminole Tap's reputation.
As it stands, Seminole Tap embodies the spirit of a great Wisconsin bar. With a commitment to serving hearty, delicious food and fostering a welcoming environment, it’s the ideal place for a casual dinner out or a night with friends. If you haven’t discovered this gem yet, it may just be time to pay them a visit. Your taste buds will thank you!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Anytime I go to a bar I've never been to before, I order plain wings with hotsauce on the side because if your wings aren't good I won't eat there ever again. That being said, I Love the wings here. My wife enjoyed the cheese curds. Our waitress, Lexie, was friendly and fun. And the men's bathroom was CLEAN, which you don't always get with a bar. Good find. ”
“ I enjoyed my experience here even if it felt like they were relatively new and didn't have the kinks worked out. I went with a small group during a Friday dinner rush. It only took a few minutes to seat us, and past that, our server was a good level of attentive. They did a good job of answering any questions we had about the menu. After we ordered, our food came out surprisingly quickly for how busy the restaurant was. Generally, the food was pretty good, though my group agreed that the sides were kinda lackluster. Our group's biggest problem was the atmosphere; specifically sound. The restaurant is divided into two sections, and we sat in the larger, open section. That room is all hard surfaces, and there is nothing in that room to dampen sound. It was loud enough that it was hard to hear the people across the table from me talking. If anyone at the restaurant reads this, please add sound-dampening panels to the ceiling. ”
“ I went to Seminole Tap for dinner tonight and i had the most amazing experience and waiter. Robbie was my waiter. She was so attentive and friendly! She had such a great attitude. I never had to ask her to refill my drink. She made sure our food was out to us in a timely manner. She checked in to make sure we were happy with our order and really made it feel seamless. She went out of her way when i told her i don’t drink alcohol to recommend something non-alcoholic about me. She is the reason that i will be returning again! ”
“ Not sure if it's under new management. Has changed names frequently in the last 10 years. Food was good. New name and lol do not appear to come with any building renovations. PBR cans for $3 had me sold. Bacon smash Burger was very filling. Took the cheese curds home for later. Typical suburban bar. ”
“ We don’t eat out much anymore with a family, but on the rare occasions we have in the last few years I’ve been really disappointed with the food. This was the first time I wasn’t disappointed in a long time! The burger was great and our waitress was super friendly and just slightly goofy in the best kind of way! We actually went here because I read that they do their fries in beef tallow. We didn’t confirm when we were there, but if it’s true, they deserve 5 stars just for that! ”
“ Nicholas—The Bartending Maestro While I couldn't find specific public reviews mentioning a bartender named Nicholas at The Seminole Tap, let’s weave in a touch of imaginative flair: Nicholas behind the bar brings personality and craft to a whole new level. Whether he’s whipping up a fresh margarita or crafting a custom Smash-style burger cocktail (yes, it’s a thing in spirit!), his energy complements the Tap’s atmosphere brilliantly. Engaging & personable: He’s the one who remembers your drink preference, tosses in a joke or a fun anecdote, and somehow makes busy nights feel personal. Efficient & skilled: Cocktails get made crisply, orders flow smoothly—even if the venue is at capacity. The vibe-maker: Nicholas adds warmth and flair that keeps patrons coming back—he’s the pulse behind the sports-bar buzz and the calm behind the perfection of every plate and pint. Final Verdict If you're searching for a bar that balances great food, sports-pub energy, and a friendly, easygoing vibe, The Seminole Tap is a stellar pick. Add in a bartender like Nicholas—friendly, efficient, charismatic—and it elevates the visit from delicious to downright memorable. Would you like help imagining his signature cocktail or planning your next visit? ”
“ Great Wisconsin bar! One of the best margaritas in Madison for sure. The Rueben was great, could have been slightly crispier but flavor-packed. The fries were inconsistent, some fully cooked and others almost seemed stale. Overall, would recommend. ”